If you’re grading cards, you’ve probably heard a dozen opinions about which penny sleeves are “best.”
But here’s the thing, most collectors are missing one key detail that matters way more than brand or type.
Keep reading to see the Grader’s Choice Pro Tip that helps preserve your cards’ condition and gives them the best chance to grade higher.
The Real Best Penny Sleeves for Grading Are Fresh Ones
If you’re getting serious about grading, here’s one prep step you can’t skip. Always use a brand-new penny sleeve before you send your card in for grading.
The Best Penny Sleeves for Grading and Why It Matters
1. Keeps Your Card Clean
New sleeves protect your card from fingerprints, dust, and micro-scratches that can happen during shipping. Old sleeves often collect tiny debris that can mark the surface without you noticing.
2. Easier for Graders
Fresh sleeves slide easier, which helps graders remove your card without bending corners or catching edges.
3. Looks More Professional
Even a perfect card can lose appeal if it looks carelessly packed. A crisp new sleeve shows the grader you treated your card like a gem.
4. Cheap, Big Impact
A sleeve costs a few cents. A downgrade costs hundreds. Easy math.
Pro Tip from Grader’s Choice
We created the Grader’s Choice Submission Kit to make this process simple. It includes fresh penny sleeves for grading, semi-rigid holders, a new microfiber cloth for cleaning cards, barcode tape for PSA, impact-resistant foam, and a self-seal shipping box. Everything you need except the cards.
How to prep right:
- Wipe your card with the microfiber cloth from the kit.
- Slide it into a new penny sleeve (never reuse an old one).
- Place it in a semi-rigid holder and secure the packaging.
That small routine could be the difference between a 9 and a 10.
With the Grader’s Choice Submission Kit, every card gets a clean sleeve, a clean surface, and the best shot possible before grading.
Final Take
Most collectors focus on brands and materials, but the truth is simple.
The best penny sleeves for grading are new ones used right before submission.
Ready to grade smarter?
Get your Grader’s Choice Submission Kit on Amazon today and prep your cards like a pro.
English
No responses yet